Exploring heat transfer

For this week’s experiment, we looked at what type of materials are the best insulators. I set up the experiment by taking 4 identical ceramic coffee mugs and filled each with 8oz. of hot water. I covered each mug with four different materials; Aluminum foil, paper, an over mitt & a down comforter. My initial readings indicated that each mug contained water that was over 120 degrees, but since my thermometer only went up to 120 degrees, I can’t be sure what the exact starting temperatures were. After thirty minutes I took another reading, but the thermometer still went up to 120 degrees so I decided to let the mugs set for an additional fifteen minutes. So after a total of forty-fiver minutes, I found that the Aluminum foil worked best, keeping the water temperature at to 118, while the paper allowed the water to cool down to 110 degrees. Both the oven mitt & down comforter kept the water at about 115 degrees. From these observations, I would say that all worked well at keeping the water hot.

If I were to teach this lesson in class, I might use the above set-up, but then do a follow-up lesson where students could look at the container instead of the material is was covered with. Since most places like Starbucks use Styrofoam or paper cups, I feel like it would be better to test those materials against a ceramic mug to determine which are better insulators, as it is more likely that those containers would be used more often in real life. I also feel like I would need more accurate thermometers, perhaps digital ones that would give more valid readings.